Things To Do
in Bay Shore

Bay Shore, located on Long Island, New York, is a charming waterfront community known for its scenic views and vibrant local culture. It boasts a rich maritime history and offers a blend of suburban tranquility and proximity to urban attractions. The area is characterized by its beautiful parks, recreational activities, and a variety of dining options.

Visitors can enjoy the serene nature of the bay while also exploring local shops and cafes.

Day Trips

Spend a day exploring around

day 1
Day 1: Exploring Bay Shore
morning
:

Start your day with breakfast at a local cafe, then head to the Bay Shore Marina for a leisurely stroll along the waterfront.

afternoon
:

Visit the Fire Island National Seashore for some sunbathing or a scenic hike, followed by lunch at a seafood restaurant nearby.

evening
:

Enjoy dinner at a popular steakhouse, and finish the night with a walk on the beach to watch the sunset.

day 2
Day 2: Culture and Nature
morning
:

Begin with a visit to the Bay Shore Historical Society to learn about the area’s history, followed by brunch at a local diner.

afternoon
:

Explore the nearby parks, such as Gardiner County Park, for hiking or picnicking, and take advantage of the beautiful trails.

evening
:

Wrap up your visit with dinner at a cozy Italian restaurant and enjoy some live music at a local bar.

Cost Guide

Prices

ItemPrice
🍔Meal at a Restaurant$20
Coffee$4
🚌Public Transport Ticket$2.75
🏨Hotel Nightly Rate$150
🍕Pizza Slice$3

Strengths and Weaknesses

  • Beautiful waterfront views and outdoor activities
  • Rich local culture and history
  • Diverse dining options catering to various tastes
  • Traffic can be congested during peak times
  • Limited nightlife options compared to larger cities
  • Seasonal weather can limit outdoor activities

Places to Visit in Bay Shore

Visit one of these nice places.

Bay Shore Marina

A picturesque spot offering beautiful views of the boats and the bay, especially at sunset.

Fire Island Lighthouse

An iconic landmark, perfect for capturing stunning coastal views.

Gardiner County Park

Offers diverse landscapes with trails and beaches, ideal for nature photography.

Culinary Guide

Food in Bay Shore

Bay Shore is a culinary delight, offering a mix of fresh seafood, local produce, and diverse dining options that reflect its vibrant community.

Bay Shore Famous Food

Signature dishes, delicacies and famous food

Clam Chowder

A creamy soup made with fresh clams, potatoes, and spices, perfect for seafood lovers.

Must-Try!

Lobster Roll

Fresh lobster meat served in a toasted bun, often accompanied by a side of fries.

Bagels

New York-style bagels, chewy and delicious, often served with cream cheese and lox.

Food Markets

Explore local food markets

Bay Shore Farmers Market

Open on weekends, featuring local produce, artisanal goods, and homemade treats.

Street Food Stalls

Various food vendors offering quick bites, including tacos, hot dogs, and ice cream.

Climate Guide

Weather

Bay Shore experiences a humid continental climate with four distinct seasons. Winters are cold, with temperatures averaging around 30°F (-1°C), while summers are warm, with highs around 80°F (27°C). Spring and fall are mild and pleasant, making them ideal for outdoor activities. Rain is common throughout the year, so it's advisable to carry an umbrella.

How to Behave

Tips on cultural norms and respectful behavior

Politeness

It’s customary to greet people with a smile and a friendly 'hello'.

Respect for Nature

Visitors are encouraged to clean up after themselves, especially in parks and natural areas.

Quiet Hours

Be mindful of noise levels in residential areas, especially during late hours.

Safety Guide

Safety

Bay Shore is generally safe, but like any community, visitors should remain vigilant. It's advisable to avoid poorly lit areas at night and keep personal belongings secure. Emergency services can be reached easily, and there are various local police stations and hospitals in proximity.

Tipping in Bay Shore

Ensure a smooth experience

Tipping in Restaurants

A standard tip of 15-20% is expected at restaurants.

Cash vs. Credit

Most places accept credit cards, but having cash for small vendors and tips is advisable.

Best Time to Visit

And what to expect in different seasons...

Spring

Mild temperatures and blooming flowers make it a great time for outdoor activities.

Summer

Warm weather draws visitors for beach activities and water sports; expect lively crowds.

Fall

Cooler weather and changing foliage provide a beautiful backdrop for hiking and photography.

Winter

Cold temperatures may deter some travelers, but winter scenery can be picturesque, and indoor attractions are plentiful.

Nightlife Guide

Bay Shore at Night

Bay Shore's nightlife scene is vibrant, featuring a mix of bars, lounges, and live music venues. Visitors can enjoy a variety of atmospheres, from laid-back pubs to lively dance clubs. There are often events like trivia nights, karaoke, and live performances, making it an engaging experience for all. The waterfront bars are particularly popular for their scenic views and relaxed ambiance.

Hiking in Bay Shore

Immerse in an unforgettable hike.

Sagtikos Park Trails

Offers a network of trails through wooded areas and wetlands, ideal for both hiking and birdwatching.

Connetquot River State Park

Features miles of scenic trails along the river, perfect for hiking, biking, and nature walks.

Airports

How to reach Bay Shore by plane.

Long Island MacArthur Airport (ISP)

Located approximately 10 miles from Bay Shore, ISP offers domestic flights and is the most convenient airport for visitors.

Getting Around

Walkability

Bay Shore is quite walkable, with many attractions, restaurants, and parks within a short distance of each other. Sidewalks are plentiful, and the waterfront areas are particularly pedestrian-friendly. However, some areas may require a car for access, especially when venturing outside the main town center.

Demographics

Explore demographics in this area.

Young Families

Many young families are drawn to Bay Shore for its community feel, good schools, and recreational activities.

Retirees

The area is also home to many retirees who appreciate the quiet lifestyle and access to nature.

Popular Sports

Explore popular sports in region.

Baseball

Local communities often host baseball games, and fans can support their teams at various local parks.

Soccer

Soccer is popular among both youth and adults, with many leagues and clubs throughout the region.

Transportation

Traffic

Traffic in Bay Shore can become congested, especially during rush hours and weekends, particularly near the waterfront and shopping areas. Public transportation options include bus services and the Long Island Rail Road, making it easy to get around without a car.

Accomodations

Find the best place to stay when visiting Bay Shore.

Dietary Restrictions

Tips for restricted diets.

Gluten-Free Options

Many restaurants offer gluten-free alternatives, including pizzas and pasta.

Vegetarian/Vegan Choices

Several eateries provide vegetarian and vegan dishes, ensuring inclusivity for all diets.

Health & Medical

Healthcare

Access to healthcare in Bay Shore is good, with several clinics and a hospital located nearby. Emergency services are prompt, and many local providers accept various insurance plans. It's advisable for travelers to have health insurance coverage for any unexpected medical needs.

Discover United States

Read more in our United States 2025 Travel Guide.

United States Travel Guide