Things To Do
in Bay Shore
Bay Shore is a coastal hamlet on the south shore of Long Island, part of the Town of Islip in Suffolk County. It sits along the Great South Bay, offering a relaxed waterfront vibe, historic storefronts, and marina views. The area serves as a gateway to Fire Island and a hub for boating, seafood, and small-town culture.
With easy rail and road access to New York City, Bay Shore blends seaside charm with convenient city connections.
Day Trips
Spend a day exploring around
Start your day with a refreshing walk along the Bay Shore waterfront, watching the sunrise over the bay. Grab a coffee from a local café and enjoy the tranquil morning atmosphere while observing the boats gliding across the water. Don't forget to take pictures of the stunning views and the colorful sky.
After lunch, visit the local parks such as Shoreline Park, where you can partake in outdoor activities like biking or kayaking. Take a leisurely stroll through the lush greenery and soak in the scenic beauty of the area. As the afternoon sun shines bright, consider visiting a nearby maritime museum to immerse yourself in the local maritime history.
In the evening, head to one of the nearby seafood restaurants to indulge in fresh catch from the local waters. Enjoy a meal on the outdoor patio, allowing the gentle breeze and ambient sounds of the bay to enhance your dining experience. After dinner, take a sunset cruise for a breathtaking view of the sun setting over the water.
Begin your morning at a local art gallery showcasing regional artists, where you can appreciate and engage with the vibrant local art scene. Attend a workshop if available, and perhaps create a small piece of art yourself. This is not only a chance to immerse yourself in creativity but also to meet locals who share your passion for art.
Spend your afternoon exploring historical landmarks and museums in Bay Shore, including the local historical society which offers insights into the town's rich heritage. Stop for lunch at a quaint diner that offers classic American fare, allowing you to fuel up for an afternoon of exploration. Check out any ongoing events or exhibitions that highlight the local culture.
In the evening, enjoy live music at a local venue or casual bar where local bands perform. The vibrant atmosphere is perfect for kicking back and mingling with locals while enjoying a drink. As the night deepens, you might find a cozy spot to unwind under the stars with friends.
Prices
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| 🍔Meal at inexpensive restaurant | $10-15 |
| 🍝Three-course dinner at mid-range restaurant | $25-40 |
| ☕Coffee or tea | $3-6 |
| 🚌Public transit ride (local buses/LIRR) | $2-7 |
| 🏨One night in mid-range hotel | $120-200 |
Strengths and Weaknesses
- Waterfront access and boating culture
- Strong seafood scene and casual dining
- Proximity to NYC and Fire Island
- Walkable town core with local shops
- Family-friendly with parks and trails
- Limited big-city nightlife
- Seasonal crowds in summer
- Fewer large-scale attractions in-town
- Parking can be challenging on peak days
- Weather can impact outdoor plans
Places to Visit in Bay Shore
Visit one of these nice places.
Golden-hour light over moored boats and calm water, with silhouettes of masts and distant ferries.
Expansive bay views, green space, and piers—great for wide-angle or candid family shots.
Colorful storefronts, docks, and reflections on the water—especially photogenic in early morning or late afternoon.
Food in Bay Shore
Bay Shore Famous Food
Signature dishes, delicacies and famous food
Chilled or warm lobster meat in a buttery roll, a seaside favorite served at many waterfront spots.
Must-Try!
Pan-seared crab cakes with remoulade or aioli, a staple at local seafood houses.
Creamy chowder loaded with clams and potatoes, a comforting starter on cooler days.
A shared platter of shellfish, corn, and sausage, seasoned with herbs and lemon.
Pasta dishes and seafood entrees reflecting regional Italian influence on the South Shore.
Food Markets
Explore local food markets
Seasonal market on Main Street with local produce, baked goods, and ready-to-eat foods—great for sampling and strolling.
On-site market offering fresh catches with simple, quick preparations for a seaside snack or meal.
Weather
How to Behave
Tips on cultural norms and respectful behavior
Greet with a smile, queue patiently, and keep noise considerate in public spaces and residential areas.
Follow posted rules on docks and piers; be mindful of tides and give priority to boats when near the water.
Safety
Tipping in Bay Shore
Ensure a smooth experience
In the U.S., tip 15-20% at dine-in restaurants; round up for smaller, casual service; tip bartenders per drink; check for any service charges on large groups.
Most places accept credit/debit cards, cash, and mobile wallets (Apple Pay, Google Pay). Some small markets or casual eateries may be cash-only.
Best Time to Visit
And what to expect in different seasons...
Warm days with humidity and frequent outdoor events; expect crowds around the waterfront, beaches, and farmers markets.
Pleasant temperatures and colorful foliage along the bay; ideal for walks, photography, and slower-paced explorations.
Cool to cold; some venues reduce hours; cozy cafés and indoor cultural events provide refuge and charm.
Rising temperatures and blooming gardens; parks and arboretums come alive with color and wildlife.
Bay Shore at Night
Hiking in Bay Shore
Immerse in an unforgettable hike.
Wooded trails, tranquil streams, and abundant birdwatching opportunities just a short drive from Bay Shore.
Extensive gardens and forested paths in Great River, ideal for strolls and photography.
Coastal park with diverse trails and bay views, popular for picnics, hiking, and wildlife viewing.
Airports
How to reach Bay Shore by plane.
Islip, NY – domestic flights and car rentals; conveniently located about 10-20 miles from Bay Shore.
New York City area; major international and domestic hub about 40-50 miles away by road.
New York City area; domestic flights hub approximately 50-60 miles away.
Walkability
Demographics
Explore demographics in this area.
Many long-term residents and newcomers choose Bay Shore for affordable housing, schools, and waterfront recreation.
A portion of residents appreciate quieter neighborhoods and access to parks and healthcare facilities.
Commuters who work in NYC or nearby towns seek a balance of coastal lifestyle and convenient transit.
A mix of cultural backgrounds contributes to varied dining options and neighborhood events.
Popular Sports
Explore popular sports in region.
Local youth and community leagues are active; many parks host games during spring and summer.
Popular in schools and clubs across Long Island, with seasonal play in spring.
South Shore waterways support recreational boating, charter fishing, and water sports.
Traffic
Accomodations
Find the best place to stay when visiting Bay Shore.
Dietary Restrictions
Tips for restricted diets.
Look for vegetable-forward dishes such as salads, grain bowls, roasted vegetables, and dairy/egg-based options; ask for modifications to suit vegetarian preferences.
Many spots offer gluten-free options or can adapt dishes; communicate dietary needs clearly and verify ingredients (especially sauces and bread).